A history of parent involvement in organized youth sport: A scoping review

Purpose / research question

The purpose of this scoping review was to provide a historical analysis of the literature on parent involvement in organized youth sport. It identified the key concepts and trajectories that define the field's foundational (1968-1981), transitional (1982-1998), and contemporary (1999-2020) periods. It used this synthesis to frame remaining gaps and future research directions.

Summary

Prior reviews of sport parenting research focused only on contemporary findings. This scoping review instead traces the full history of the field back to its origins in the late 1960s. The authors ran an iterative multi-stage search across PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, PsycINFO and SportDiscus, plus citation-chasing and a final validation search. This produced a final population of 242 peer-reviewed English-language articles (1968-2020). Each was coded for 14 data points, including sample characteristics, methods, findings and take-home messages.

Rather than organising the synthesis by decade, the authors identified three qualitatively distinct periods, each marked by a paradigm-shifting publication. The foundational period (1968-1981) began with Felker's work on fathers' sport interest and boys' self-concept. It was grounded largely in social learning theory, and focused on how parents' own interest in sport shaped children's socialization and the parent-child relationship.

The transitional period (1982-1998) began with Gould and colleagues' attrition research. It was marked by a shift from descriptive, atheoretical studies toward theory-driven research on parental pressure and support, gender-role socialization, and children's psychosocial outcomes. This period also saw the formal operationalization of 'parental involvement' as a pressure-support construct (Leff & Hoyle, 1995).

The contemporary period (1999-2020) began with Côté's work on family dynamics and talent development. It is characterised by greater methodological diversity, including qualitative designs. It also brought a widened focus on parents' own experiences and motivations, not just their effects on children, multiple stakeholder perspectives, and a growing but still limited body of evidence-based parent education programs.

This summary was drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by the editor for accuracy. It is not a substitute for the original publication — see Source above.

Contribution to the field Editor's interpretation

This review's central contribution is corrective. It shows that sport parenting research is not a 'new' field, as contemporary reviews might suggest, but one with over 50 years of accumulated history. It gives that history an organising structure -- foundational, transitional, contemporary -- that later work can be located within.

It functions almost as a field map. For example, it shows how Harwood & Knight's stress research, Holt et al.'s observational work, and digital parent-education studies like Thrower et al. and Tamminen et al. all sit within the 'contemporary period' trajectory it describes. Its critique that the literature remains skewed toward White, middle or upper-class, Western, two-parent samples is also a useful lens for assessing the limitations of the current evidence base more broadly.

Key findings

  • Sport parenting research dates back to the late 1960s and has grown into a substantial, 242-article body of literature spanning three distinct historical periods.
  • Early research (1968-1998) was largely descriptive and atheoretical, focused on how parents' own sport interest shaped children's socialization into sport.
  • From the late 1990s onward, research shifted toward understanding parents' own experiences, motivations, and the diverse factors shaping their involvement, not just its effects on children.
  • The field has consistently found that parental support is linked to positive outcomes (enjoyment, self-esteem, coping) while pressure and overly directive behaviour are linked to negative outcomes (anxiety, reduced motivation, dropout).
  • Existing research remains heavily skewed toward White, middle-to-upper-class, Western, two-parent families, limiting how representative current knowledge is.

Practical implications

The authors argue that evidence-based parent education should move beyond a "one size fits all" approach.
It should instead be individualised to the specific needs and context of each family.
Programs should be evaluated not just for short-term knowledge gains, but for long-term behaviour change.
Researchers and practitioners should also look beyond simply educating parents directly.
For instance, they could build the capacity of coaches and sport organisations to work more effectively with parents.
They could also address structural barriers, such as low attendance at workshops, through club-level culture change rather than relying solely on individual-level intervention.

Limitations

This is a scoping review of English-language, peer-reviewed journal articles only.
It excludes books, dissertations, conference proceedings and non-English literature.
By definition, it also excludes informal or unorganised play contexts.
The underlying literature it synthesises is itself heavily skewed toward White, middle or upper-class, Western — especially US — samples and traditional two-parent households.
The authors acknowledge this limits how representative the accumulated "historical" knowledge base actually is.

Research gaps

Who has been studied: there is a need for more diverse samples across gender, family structure, socioeconomic status, culture, country and sport, including minoritized youth populations.
What has been studied: there is a need to move from describing what parents do toward explaining how and why, drawing on a wider range of theories such as family systems theory and attachment theory, and treating parents as one part of a broader youth sport system.
How studies have been conducted: there is a need for more longitudinal, observational, and methodologically varied designs, beyond single-time-point self-report surveys.
How research has been used in practice: there is a need for more rigorously evaluated, individualised parent-education programs, and for approaches that engage coaches and organisations, not just parents directly.